As a fire engineer, my role is to assist architects with the fire safety aspects of a building’s design. It is now standard for architects to send me pdf copies of electronically-created drawings. But last week, I received a pdf that reminded me of my younger days and made my heart sing – a hand-drawn proposed floor plan.
When I first began my career over 30 years ago, hand-drawn plans were the norm. It was a time of DOS computer operating systems, when you needed to remember what the function keys did. It was a time before email, when phone calls and in-person meetings were the norm and hard copy letters and memos were a thing.
Today, things are very different. I spend my life answering emails, and meetings are carried out via video call. I still visit site in person but I’m also able to create 3D models and visualise smoke movement digitally.
Yet despite all of the technological advancements, some things have not changed. In 2006, Building Regulation 16B came into force. This Regulation requires the person carrying out building work to provide fire safety information to the Responsible Person on completion of the works or on occupation[1]. When the Building Regulations 2010 came into force, this requirement was renumbered to Regulation 38 rather than Regulation 16B. What hasn’t changed over those 20 years to date is that this Regulation has never really been properly carried out or enforced.
What does this mean in practice? Well, from my perspective, I see a huge amount of information and drawings being created during design and throughout construction of a project. Regulation 38 then stipulates that this information on the building should be updated to an as-built form and provided to the person responsible for the ongoing management of the building. This information will then be used to manage the building effectively going forward.
Practically, it’s important that the information provided to the Responsible Person is as-built so that its current and up-to-date; so it can be relied upon. Such information would include floor plans, information about the fire strategy for the building and about any fire safety systems designed into the building. We also want documented any assumptions regarding the management of the building. This information can then also be used by those carrying out a fire risk assessment of the building.
For more complex buildings, there is additional information that’s required under Regulation 38. In these cases, we might be looking for a written fire strategy, a cause and effect matrix for fire safety systems such as the fire alarm, and other records such as commissioning certification and specifications.
To ensure that all this information is provided at handover, there needs to be a plan in place from the beginning of the project regarding what information needs to be obtained and how the information will be collected and collated throughout the project. This is a significant piece of work and trying to obtain all of this information once the building is complete, when service routes are now hidden behind plasterboard and cavity barriers can’t be seen, inevitably leads to poor quality information being handed over….if anything is handed over at all.
Despite pricing each job with an optional extra of updating the fire strategy to an as-built version, it is rare for projects to instruct me to do this aspect. From my work as an expert witness for cladding disputes, I am also aware that drawings stamped “As-built” aren’t always telling the truth – I have carried out enough intrusive inspections to be able to say this with confidence. When I visit occupied buildings to undertake a fire risk assessment, I ask for the fire strategy. Almost always, I am met with either a shoulder shrug and “we don’t have anything” or I am shown a wall of ring binders and told “everything’s in there…somewhere”. In my experience, the likelihood of receiving clearly labelled, as-built files (hard copy or electronic) which can be relied upon are slim to none. All this, twenty years after this Building Regulation came into force requiring fire safety information to be provided at handover.
Against this backdrop, there’s the added complication of emerging technology. We now have 3D modelling, BIM, online dropboxes and project planning software. All of these systems will be different for each project and require passwords and access protocols. For the consultants who work across multiple projects, this makes the situation challenging and time-consuming. For the client who doesn’t possess the software to read BIM models, this electronic information is inaccessible; the labour resource requirements to keep such models current following day-to-day maintenance is unrealistic.
In his book Practically Radical (Summary), William C Taylor said “Just because we can, doesn’t mean we should”. In relation to electronic building information, I agree with him. The poet Robert Browning said “Less is more”. I wholeheartedly agree with him in relation to electronic building information. We are undoubtedly running before we can walk at present. I would very much like to see us accept the reality of where we are currently in relation to electronic building information and go back to basics; ask clients what information they will be able to utilise and how they want it presented at handover. Doing this in the early stages of the project ensures we can provide meaningful and useful information. Stephen R Covey said “Begin with the end in mind”. I encourage you to start your next building project with a clear vision of the desired outcome for building information, based on your client’s ongoing resources, capabilities, wants and needs.
For buildings where the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 (as amended) applies.

